read_icb_extents hardcoded an 8-byte Short-AD stride for every file. Large
BD-ROM .m2ts streams use 16-byte Long ADs; striding them as Short ADs reads
descriptor #0 correctly (length+lba align) but lands #1 in the middle of the
first Long AD (its zero impl_use bytes). The AD-list terminator (data_len==0
=> break) then fired on that zero and stopped after the first extent, so every
multi-extent title truncated at ~1 GiB. The same reader backs read_file, so
disc AACS-input files (/AACS/*.inf) and the m2ts mux extents were both
affected.
Read the ICB Tag flags (AD type) and stride 8/16/20 bytes for Short/Long/
Extended ADs accordingly; Extended ADs carry the lba at off+12.
aacs: extract trim_mkb and restore its guard so an MKB whose content length
the parser cannot determine (mkb_content_len == 0) is returned intact instead
of truncated to empty.
Regression tests: Long-AD read_icb_extents returns all extents; Long-AD
read_file returns full content; trim_mkb never zeroes an unrecognised MKB.
Library-wide review-and-fix pass: tightened AACS keydb/handshake/variant
handling and trailing-partial-unit policy, corrected MPLS mark offset and
added UDF allocation bounds, hardened the mux/codec framing and M2TS paths,
guarded SCSI READ CAPACITY short transfers and unified error mapping, added
overflow guards on untrusted disc input, and made prefetch shutdown
deterministic. Release profile now builds with thin LTO + single codegen unit.
Subtitle/DVD output-corruption + stream-mapping coverage fixes.
1. DVD subtitle/audio track-mapping collision (CRITICAL). The PS path
routed 0xBD private-stream packets to a track via (sub_id & 0x1F)+1,
so VobSub subtitle sub-id 0x20+j aliased audio track j+1: subtitle
PES was fed to the AC-3 parser and the real subtitle track got
nothing. Route by the canonical DVD PID instead via a new
PsPacket::dvd_pid() that mirrors scan_dvd_titles' PID assignment
(video 0xE0, audio 0xBD00+i, subtitle 0x20+j), then look up the
track in pid_to_track. Fixed identically at all three sites
(pipelined_stream consume_ps, disc.rs live feed, disc.rs EOF flush).
Unmappable/unmapped packets now WARN instead of silently dropping.
2. PGS flush() missing. PgsParser inherited the no-op default flush, so
the last subtitle of every PGS track (emitted only when a following
PCS arrives) was dropped at EOF. Implemented flush() to drain the
pending display set (duration_ns: None for the trailing block).
3. DVD VobSub multi-PES SPU not reassembled. A subpicture unit larger
than one PES spans multiple PES (only the head carries a PTS).
DvdSubParser is now stateful: it buffers per sub-stream until the
leading 2-byte SPU_size is satisfied, inherits the head PTS, and
emits one Frame. flush() drains a truncated trailing SPU at EOF.
4. One-table hygiene. scan_streams had a duplicate stream_type->Codec
table that had drifted from Codec::from_coding_type (missing 0x80
LPCM, 0x85 mapped to DTS-HD MA vs HR, etc.). scan_streams now uses
from_coding_type plus a new Codec::kind()/CodecKind category split,
so the two mappings can never diverge. Silent drops in
scan_streams and bluray STN parsing now WARN with PID + type.
Tests: dvd_pid mapping + subtitle/audio collision regression, PGS
final-subtitle flush, VobSub multi-PES reassembly + EOF flush,
scan_streams 0x80 LPCM via from_coding_type.
H.264 stored SPS/PPS in single Option slots and always stripped them
from frame data, so a mid-title parameter-set redefinition (same id,
different body) was lost — those frames decoded against the stale avcC
copy the player re-applies at each keyframe. Same defect class as the
HEVC PPS-redefinition bug. Mirror that fix: emit a changed SPS/PPS
in-band at every occurrence; strip only the first-seen / identical ones.
Also guard avcC's 16-bit NAL length fields: a param set > 65535 bytes
truncated the length while appending all bytes. Return None instead.
codec_private() hardcoded 8-bit 4:2:0 in the hvcC fixed header, wrong for
10-bit Main 10 UHD (essentially all UHD). Parse chroma_format_idc and
bit_depth_luma/chroma_minus8 from the SPS RBSP (with emulation-prevention
removal and sub-layer profile_tier_level handling) and emit the real
values; fall back to 8-bit 4:2:0 only if the SPS can't be parsed.
Also guard the 16-bit NAL length fields: a param set larger than 65535
bytes would truncate the length while appending all bytes, mis-framing
the record. Return None instead of emitting a corrupt hvcC.
A continuation PES (one that merely extends a TrueHD AU spanning PES
packets) carries its own later PTS, which the parser was adopting
mid-assembly, snapping the AU's timestamp and breaking the monotonic
per-AU cadence (A/V drift). Capture the PTS base only when the
reassembly buffer is empty, i.e. when a PES actually begins a new AU.
When two access units flushed in one parse() call (a core arriving in an
earlier PES than the PES that closes the unit, the standard DTS-HD MA
core+extension-as-separate-PES layout), the second AU inherited the
latest PES's PTS instead of its own core's.
Track per-PES PTS markers keyed by buffer offset and stamp each emitted
AU with the PTS of the PES covering its first byte, rebasing markers on
every front drain. Each AU now keeps its own core's timestamp.
Extends two_cores_back_to_back to assert PTS; adds cross-PES coverage.
Two defects:
- Ac3Parser inherited the no-op default flush(), so a complete final
frame still buffered at end-of-stream was dropped (~32 ms of audio
lost). Add a flush() that drains a complete buffered frame, mirroring
dts.rs.
- Every frame in one parse() call was stamped with the single PES PTS,
collapsing their timecodes and drifting A/V. Compute a base PTS once
per call, then advance per frame by the frame's own duration (AC-3 =
1536 samples; E-AC-3 from numblkscod), converting samples->ns at the
stream sample rate (fscod). Each Frame now carries duration_ns.
MetaStream::Video dropped color_space on from_title/to_title, hardcoding
BT.709 on the way back. HDR titles (BT.2020) lost their color metadata.
Add a color_space field, populate it in from_title, and use it in
to_title. For pre-0.30.7 metadata that has no color_space, derive it from
the preserved hdr field (all HDR formats are BT.2020, SDR is BT.709).
Adds ColorSpace::id() + FromStr for serialization round-trip.
Fight Club redefines PPS id 0 mid-title; the parser froze the first PPS into
codecPrivate and stripped the rest, so the redefined segment decoded against
the wrong PPS (CABAC/cu_qp_delta desync, intact framing). Now any VPS/SPS/PPS
whose body differs from the codecPrivate copy is emitted in-band at every
occurrence, overriding the hvcC copy a player re-applies per keyframe. Proven:
Fight Club re-mux decode errors 320+ -> 0 across all corrupt regions.
Also adds aacs::unit_key_validates (1-block early-reject UK validation) and
ts_sync_count/ts_packet_total helpers.
Fixes the non-monotonic DTS ffmpeg/players reject (observed on Fight Club audio
streams 16/18: "14061 >= 14060"). Some audio PES PTS truncate to the same
millisecond as the prior frame, or tick back 1ms from rounding. The MKV writer
now tracks the last block timecode per track and nudges a non-increasing one to
prev+1ms (sub-frame, inaudible, A/V sync unaffected at ms granularity), recorded
only for frames actually written. New helper monotonic_ts() + unit test.
Independent of the separate HEVC slice-payload corruption investigation.
Add `DiscInputs.volume_label: Option<String>` — the disc's human title (UDF/ISO
volume identifier, else BDMV <di:name>), populated by Disc::inputs() from the
scan. Identity only, no secret, not used in any AACS derivation; lets a key
source forward the title so a key service can catalog disc_hash → title.
The video codec parsers (HEVC, H.264, VC-1, MPEG-2) used
pes.dts.or(pes.pts) as each frame's timestamp. MKV block timecodes
are presentation timestamps; frames are stored in decode order and
the player reorders for display by timecode. Using DTS makes the
timecode monotonic in storage order, presenting B-frames in decode
order — visible motion judder / wrong frames on playback, and
PTS-based seeking lands on the wrong frame.
The compressed video was always byte-correct (verified by NAL-level
diff against a known-good demux); this was purely a timestamp defect
affecting every B-frame title. Fix: prefer PTS (pes.pts.or(pes.dts)).
Verified on a real UHD iso->mkv: emitted PTS now reorders for
B-frames identically to a reference muxer.
Update the two tests that asserted the old DTS-preferred behavior and
add an HEVC regression test pinning PTS as the block timecode.
Audit-driven fixes (rounds 1–3):
- hevc: correct hvcC profile/level SPS offsets (HEVC has a 2-byte NAL header)
- mkv: map all DTS variants to the registered A_DTS codec id; force a new
cluster before the i16 cluster-relative timestamp can overflow
- ebml/mkvstream: bound untrusted EBML sizes (no multi-GB allocs); reject
uint>8 (was an OOB panic) and non-{0,4,8} float widths (were a desync)
- ts: skip PES-header bytes that span a TS packet boundary; add the PMT
section_len/prog_info_len bounds the PAT parser already had
- ac3: preserve a 0x0B77 syncword split across a PES boundary; cap buffer
- dts: validate each next-core boundary by decoded core size (a 0x7FFE8001
pattern inside XLL payload no longer false-splits/drops the lossless
extension); reject sub-minimum core frames; fix forced-emit PTS base
- lpcm: DVD program-stream PCM no longer double-strips the BD LPCM header
- vc1/mpeg2: do not emit a parameter-set-only PES as a standalone frame
- pgs/truehd: cap the pending reassembly buffer (parity with ac3/dts)
- aacs: ts_syncs_intact uses the exact packet count
- prefetched: capacity-guard the recycled-buffer set_len
- Cargo.toml: exclude project docs from the published crate
Convergence: a third independent audit pass found no remaining material
(CRITICAL/HIGH/MEDIUM) issues. Full precommit (fmt + clippy -D + tests,
Rust 1.86) green.
decrypt_with now takes the disc's encrypted content samples and, after
deriving the candidate unit keys, confirms at least one de-scrambles a real
aligned unit before committing them. A wrong key (a keydb VK that doesn't
match the disc, a stale UK) is rejected with AacsKeyRejected instead of
silently applying garbage unit keys. Conservative by design: with no samples
(resume / mapfile cache) it accepts as before, leaving those paths unchanged.
The KeySource trait becomes a stateful provider — next_key hands one candidate
at a time (the source owns the order) and reports exhaustion, replacing the
all-at-once resolve; errored() distinguishes a failed source from a clean
no-key.
DTS-HD MA/HRA access units on Blu-ray are a DTS core frame (sync
0x7FFE8001) followed by one or more DTS extension substreams (sync
0x64582025) carrying the lossless audio. Ground-truthing the Dunkirk
ISO showed the m2ts demuxer hands these out as SEPARATE PES packets on
the same PID: one core PES (exactly core-sized, nothing trailing), then
the extension substreams in following PES packets with their own later
PTS.
The old DtsParser emitted one frame per PES the moment a core frame was
complete, and dropped any PES with no core sync. So every core became a
core-only (lossy) frame and the extension PES packets were discarded as
junk -- silently downgrading the track to lossy DTS core (1557 kb/s CBR,
16-bit) instead of DTS-HD MA (VBR, 24-bit lossless).
Rewrite the parser to assemble across PES boundaries: an access unit
runs from its core sync up to (but not including) the NEXT core sync, so
the core plus every following extension substream stays together. Add a
CodecParser::flush() (default empty) called at end-of-stream by both the
pipelined and inline DiscStream mux paths to drain the final buffered
unit. A 64 KiB cap guarantees forward progress and never stalls if a
boundary can't be found.
Validated on the rip1 testbed: Dunkirk eng+ger and Fight Club eng main
audio now ffprobe as profile=DTS-HD MA (Fight Club eng at 24-bit), with
VBR packet sizes (~2716-2788 B) well above the old fixed 2012 B lossy
core. Genuinely-lossy DTS dub tracks are left untouched.
When an AACS-encrypted ISO is muxed with decryption requested (not --raw)
but key resolution yielded no usable key, input() proceeded to mux the
still-encrypted stream — emitting ~100 MB of garbage (no TS syncs, demuxer
emits nothing) and sometimes spinning for tens of minutes.
Add a cheap result-check in resolve::input()'s Iso branch via the pure
predicate aacs_key_missing(raw, has_aacs, keys): when decryption is
requested AND the disc carries AACS state AND decrypt_keys() is None,
return new Error::NoDiscKey { disc_hash } (E7022) before muxing. The
40-hex disc hash is sourced from AacsState::disc_hash. --raw and
non-AACS (unencrypted / CSS) discs are unaffected. Unit-tested.
correct_truehd_channels() probes the first DECRYPTED access units of the
chosen title (TrueHD PIDs, bounded 8 MiB read of the first extent) and
sets AudioStream.channels from the MLP major sync — fixing the MPLS
audio_format understatement (5.1 declared on a 7.1/Atmos TrueHD track).
Regenerates the basic codec label for the corrected count; richer
editorial labels are left untouched. Wired in resolve.rs input() for
iso:// after decrypt_with (the m2ts is only decryptable post-key), using
a fresh reader so the mux reader is undisturbed. generate_audio_label
made pub(crate).
Adds truehd_channels(format_info) + truehd_channels_from_stream(): the
real presentation channel count (8ch/7.1 when present, else 6ch/5.1)
from the TrueHD major sync, which the MPLS audio_format base field
understates (declares 5.1 even on a 7.1/Atmos track — the Dune case).
Per the MLP spec presentation channel-assignment masks. 3 unit tests.
This is the decoder; wiring it to correct AudioStream.channels requires
a mux-time probe of the DECRYPTED audio payload (the channel truth isn't
readable at scan — the m2ts is AACS-encrypted until the key is applied
at mux), to be added + validated on a real rip.
With the EL now carried (mpls PID fix), the MKV writer tags the Dolby
Vision layer so players/mediainfo recognise it: a BlockAdditionMapping
(0x41E4) with BlockAddIDType 'dvcC' and a DOVIDecoderConfigurationRecord
(profile 7, bl+el+rpu present) on the DV-layer video track. Disc
Profile 7 dual-layer is preserved losslessly as a second video track
(archival-correct, MakeMKV-equivalent); M2TS carries the EL as a native
second video PID with no extra signaling needed.
Adds dolby_vision_config() + a profile-7 dvcC unit test. End-to-end DV
recognition (mediainfo / playback) to be confirmed on a full rip.
parse_stream_entry only read the PID for stream-entry type 1 (a stream
in the PlayItem's own clip), returning PID 0 for every other type. The
Dolby Vision enhancement layer uses type 4 (verified on Wicked + Dune:
se_len=9 type=0x04 [00 10 15] -> PID 0x1015), so the EL fell through to
PID 0x0000 and was silently dropped by the demux/mux — Dolby Vision lost.
Now the PID offset is keyed off the entry type per the BD stream_entry()
layout: type 1 -> +2, type 2 -> +4, type 3/4 -> +3. The DV EL now
resolves to its real PID (0x1015) so it is demuxed and carried as a
stream through the PES layer to every writer (M2TS carries dual-PID DV
natively; the MKV writer's DV signaling is the format-specific piece).
The DTS parser emitted a core-only frame and discarded the trailing
DTS-HD extension substream whenever the extension straddled a PES
boundary (it advanced past only the core, then re-synced on the core
syncword, skipping the leftover extension bytes). That silently
downgrades DTS-HD MA / HRA to lossy DTS core.
Now: when an extension sync is visible after the core — full, or a
partial prefix at the buffer edge — wait for the full extension instead
of splitting it off; only 'nothing after the core' (final unit / EOF,
no parser flush) is taken as a genuine lossy core-only unit. Adds a
boundary-split regression test asserting core+extension is preserved.
Two validated audio-correctness fixes (proven on real discs Wicked/
Paddington/Dune/Fight Club via head-captures):
labels: apply_labels now derives the codec/channel descriptor from the
stream's OWN codec/channels unless the parser's codec_hint is BOTH
consistent with it AND richer (e.g. "Dolby Atmos" on a TrueHD stream).
A mis-bound hint ("AC-3 2.0" on a TrueHD track) is rejected and the
stream's own codec used — killing the cross-labeled shuffle (Wicked) and
the compat-core mislabel (Paddington), while keeping rich hints and
normalizing plain ones to uniform marketing names. (codec_hint_consistent
+ codec_hint_adds_detail, 5 tests.)
disc: canonical_title_order gains an audio-richness tiebreak
(lossless > channels > track-count) for titles that tie on
duration+clips — so a movie authored as a full-audio playlist plus a
stereo-only twin (Fight Club 00800 vs 00004) picks the full-audio one
instead of falling to array order.
- mux input(): propagate a failed decrypt_with rather than muxing an
undecryptable stream silently (review M6).
- Scrub synthetic but key-SHAPED hex (HOST_PRIV_KEY/DEVICE_KEY/disc-entry) from
the keydb parser tests to obvious zero/repeated-byte placeholders. No real or
real-looking key material in code.
The library no longer loads a keydb anywhere. The scan path always captures the
disc's AACS inputs (MKB, VID, Unit_Key_RO.inf) and resolves NO key; a caller
resolves a Key from a key source and applies it via Disc::decrypt_with.
- ScanOptions loses keydb_path / unit_key / disable_keydb (and the path search);
it now carries only optional DriveCredentials (host certs) for the live-drive
AACS handshake. do_handshake_cert uses those instead of loading the keydb.
An unlocked / LibreDrive drive takes the OEM Volume-ID path and needs none.
- The mux input() path takes caller-resolved unit_keys instead of a keydb_path,
and applies them via decrypt_with.
- Deleted the now-dead inline resolve_encryption / resolve_encryption_static.
All 700+ lib tests pass.
The VID-only scan path stashed MKB_RO/RW raw — those files are allocated to a
fixed ~128 MiB and zero-padded, so the MKB on AacsState (consumed by
Disc::inputs() and the device/processing-key decrypt_with derivation) was the
full pad, not the ~few-MB record stream. Trim to mkb_content_len, matching
read_aacs_inputs.
A source that validates server-side against ciphertext (an online key service)
needs encrypted content samples; one that keys on disc identity (keydb, mapfile)
does not. needs_samples() lets the caller skip the extra disc read unless a
configured source actually needs it. Defaults false.
An online key service validates a candidate against real ciphertext, so it
needs a few encrypted content sample units. Add a samples field to DiscInputs;
Disc::inputs() leaves it empty (reading content needs the disc reader, which
scan does not retain) for the application to fill.
The library now describes the key-source abstraction it consumes, while the
concrete sources live in a companion crate. A KeySource looks a disc up from
its DiscInputs (disc hash, volume id, MKB, Unit_Key_RO.inf) and returns a Key;
the library derives down and decrypts. Sources do no derivation.
Disc::inputs() exposes those inputs from a scanned disc.
Key::Media now carries a Vec of candidate media keys rather than one: a media
key is MKB-scoped, so a source hands its whole pool and the library picks the
one that verifies against the disc's MKB. That mirrors Device/Processing and
keeps key selection (a derivation step) inside the library.
Disc::decrypt_with now takes Device / Processing / Media / Volume keys in
addition to Unit. A caller hands in whatever level it resolved and the
library derives down the AACS chain to the per-CPS-unit keys, then
decrypts:
Device -> MKB walk -> media key -> VUK -> per-CPS unit keys
Processing -> MKB -> media key -> VUK -> per-CPS unit keys
Media -> Volume ID -> VUK -> per-CPS unit keys
Volume -> Unit_Key_RO.inf, one unit key per CPS unit
Unit -> used directly (terminal)
Derivation stays centralized in the version-dispatched resolver
(1.0 / 2.0 / 2.1), fed by a single-key provider built from the supplied
key — no new crypto. Volume notably does NOT stop at the volume key: it
decrypts every CPS unit's key.
Scan stashes the AACS inputs (Unit_Key_RO.inf and MKB) on AacsState so an
out-of-band decrypt_with can derive without re-reading the disc.
Non-breaking: Key is #[non_exhaustive] and the existing Unit path is
unchanged. New tests cover the Volume -> per-CPS derive-down, the
missing-inputs error, and the no-units rejection.
scan now stashes the raw Unit_Key_RO.inf + MKB bytes on AacsState (via
resolve_vid_only, the disable_keydb path), so an external key-resolver can
derive unit keys from a resolved VUK without re-reading the disc — the
foundation for moving lookup/derivation out of libfreemkv. Additive: the keydb
path is untouched, all existing constructors default the new fields empty.
584 lib tests green. Builds on the KeyOrigin rename + the Key/decrypt_with API.
Disambiguates the key vocabulary: Key (the input handed to decrypt_with),
key sources (the resolver's lookup list), and KeyOrigin (how a key was
resolved). Internal-only rename — no dependents import it.
Add libfreemkv::Key (non_exhaustive; Unit wired) + Disc::decrypt_with(Key) — the
caller resolves a key from any source and hands it in; the library decrypts with
no keydb/network of its own. inject_unit_keys now synthesizes a minimal
ExternalUk AACS state when a scan built none (no keydb at scan time), so a disc
keyed at sweep but scanned without a keydb still decrypts from its mapfile UK
instead of reporting E8005 and deferring the mux forever. Tests cover the
synthesize, replace, empty->None, and decrypt_with paths.
A keyed disc now writes its decrypted AACS unit keys to the mapfile header
(# freemkv-uk: <cps>:<hex>); an unresolved disc writes only the VID. The two are
mutually exclusive (set_unit_keys clears the VID) — unit keys are the final
answer, so deferred-mux / resume decrypts directly with no key lookup, while the
VID alone is the 'still unresolved, retry' marker. CopyOptions/SweepOptions carry
the keys (written when present, else the VID); Disc::inject_unit_keys applies
mapfile-recovered keys to a scanned disc. Round-trip test added.
Rename is_unit_encrypted -> is_aacs_scrambled and decide encryption from the unit's MPEG-TS sync bytes (destroyed by the encrypted body) instead of the TP_extra copy-control (byte 0) or TS scrambling-control (byte 7) flags, which discs do not set reliably. One shared predicate now backs the decrypt gate and out-of-band key validation, so callers agree on what 'encrypted' means. Decryption restores the syncs, so a decrypted unit reads as clear and there is no flag to clear.
is_unit_encrypted read the TP_extra copy-control bits (byte 0), which are a
copy-permission flag, not an encryption flag. On discs whose sampled units are
clear navigation packets (PAT/PMT) those bits can be set while the unit is not
scrambled, so a correct Unit Key was used to 'decrypt' already-plaintext data,
produced garbage, and the key was wrongly treated as failing.
Read the actual flag instead: the TS transport_scrambling_control bits (top two
of TS-header byte 3 = byte 7 of the aligned unit, inside the clear seed). AACS
encrypts whole aligned units, so this one packet's TSC reflects the unit.
decrypt_unit now clears the TSC bits of every packet on the way out so the
result is valid unscrambled TS. Tests updated to the TSC flag.
keydb stores Media Keys per-disc, but an MK is MKB-scoped (shared across a
pressing/MKB-family). A disc whose own hash/VID isn't keyed can still resolve
if any stored MK verifies against its MKB. New path 2.5 (between PK and the
VID lookup) collects the distinct MK pool from the providers, km_verifies each
against the disc MKB, and on a UNIQUE pass derives VUK (with the disc VID) then
the UK — matching the online resolver's behavior so local keydb mode resolves
the same discs (e.g. an MK present in keydb under a sibling pressing).
km_verifies is one AES-D + magic check per candidate (cheap). Adds
KeyProvider::media_keys() + a path-2.5 unit test.
- mkb_content_len walks the MKB record stream and returns where it ends,
so callers can drop the trailing zero padding. MKB files are allocated
to a fixed size (~128 MiB) with records at the front; both MKB_RO and
MKB_RW can be padded. read_aacs_inputs* now trim to the real records
(~few MB) instead of shipping ~128 MiB of zeros.
- decrypt_keys() returns None when unit_keys is empty: an AACS state that
carries only a VID (out-of-band resolution, pre-key) is 'encrypted, no
keys', not a usable empty key set.
- read_aacs_inputs / read_aacs_inputs_from_drive now read MKB_RO.inf first.
MKB_RW.inf is a fixed ~128 MiB rewritable region that is mostly zero
padding; reading it shipped 124 MiB of nothing. MKB_RO is the real,
correctly-sized MKB (a few MB). Fall back to RW only if RO is absent.
- disable_keydb no longer drops the Volume ID. A caller resolving Unit Keys
out-of-band needs the VID (on-disc content read during the handshake).
New resolve_vid_only builds a keys-free AacsState carrying just the VID +
version metadata, so the disc reports 'encrypted, no keys' (resolved
out-of-band) instead of discarding the VID.
Matthew Jackson